Utopia Temple
Not logged inLoginRegister158,962 Registered Users

Utopia Angel v2.23b Utopia Homepage Java Chat Public Forums Web-Mail

"Constantly rising DPA" by Nasrudin
It doesn't matter what we do to change military costs, buildings effectiveness, improve the benefits of attacking vs. defending, or try to change people's attitude in general. DPA and OPA will still be constantly rising throughout the round. It's a universal law of Utopia. Let me explain.

In the beginning of the round, all provinces buy some defense because they expect the other provinces to become hostile later. So far so good :) When protection ends, people start attacking eachother. The targets are right from the beginning those provinces that has the lowest DPA. This is natural, because low DPA means landfat, and attacking landfat provinces result in higher gains.

A little into the round the DPA will stabilize at some point 20 DPA (say), because provinces that get hit will raise their DPA, and because the word goes around that 20 DPA is standard right now. (People in general will do/pay anything to avoid being considered an easy target)

Attackers will, in an attempt to keep attacking, raise their OPA to 22 or so. This will after a little while cause a new raise in DPA, and so on and so on. This is the universal law: That for each ACTION there is an equal and opposite REACTION, and in this case it applies to Utopia.

Halfway through the game or so, draft rate and utilization (in the old days draft rate only) sets a natural limit to how much DPA and OPA can be further strengthened. Since every province has to have higher DPA than OPA, it follows that provinces can no longer attack provinces close to their own size. And so they look for smaller targets. This is where we start complaining about the rising DPA.

What happens if we lower the cost of offensive troops? It would improve attacking economies, but it would not affect the DPA race.

What happens if we make Homes house less people? Or more people? None of those would affect the DPA race (but they might change building strategies).

We can cap DPA and OPA, sure that would stop the DPA race, but hardly satisfactory in a strategy war game? (Imagine a province with less than max DPA - what a giveaway)

The ONLY thing I can think of that might work is if we put a stop to random grabs, and have kingdoms fight only one other kingdom at a time. Let me explain that. It would give a province the option of *sometimes* compromising defense, because its enemies would be a strange looking bunch of 25 unequally sized provinces, and not this statistical 'bulk' of 50,000 provinces, all closely monitering its DPA around the clock. In fact this might introduce the element of military tactics into Utopia.

- Nasrudin (5-Oct-2000)

Readers' Comments

Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 All    Next »
AuthorComment
dot
Unregistered User
(15-Oct-2000 07:31 am)
Report
nothing thought through... but how about a bigger exponential scale for military costs?
Anonymous
Unregistered User
(15-Oct-2000 11:55 am)
Report
It still wouldn&#039t stop us defending races to go attacking. It&#039ll just make us go for 60dpa and 10tpa. And all the attacking provinces will just be harmed more because our thieves ratio is still very high. I don&#039t think anything can stop us defending and thieving.
Thalura
Unregistered User
(15-Oct-2000 03:15 pm)
Report
I think another solution would be, to put a general limit on size for attacks. To force people, to attack allways within a +25/-20% range. like this all defence would naturally drop, as noone will have to defend against someone 50% larger then him.
Justin
Unregistered User
(16-Oct-2000 10:32 am)
Report
No, that would wreck the part of the game. Some people like to newbie-bash. Also, Mehul already made bonuses on honor for challenging the bigger players, and you lose honor if you attack a smaller province when not in a war. So I guess Anonomous is right. Nothing can stop us thieves. You do something to try to stop us, we&#039ll just higher our homes%.

So I guess what we can do is to lower a lot more honor, about 500, if the target is much smaller than you.
Jiggs CW
Unregistered User
(19-Oct-2000 06:00 pm)
Report
Not a bad idea, still it could be easy to abuse, further clarification is needed. Also the problem is that in wars only the large provs tned to gain anyhting.
Page: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 All    Next »

Post your Comment
In order to post your comment, you have to be logged into your account

[ Login ]     [ Register an Account ]

[ Email me on new posts ]     [ Email this to a friend ]